Thursday, May 15, 2014

NYT OPed: The Commencement Bigots

Excerpt...
Condoleezza Rice was scheduled to give the 248th anniversary commencement address at Rutgers University this coming Sunday. She canceled after a small knot of protesters pressured the university. It’s no contest who showed more class.

Near as I can tell, the forces of intolerance objected to her role in the Iraq war. O.K. And by shutting her down, the point is ... what? That extremism, whether in the climate-denial echo chamber of Republican Party elites or in the fragile zone of college faculty lounges, is the worst enemy of free speech.

Thanks to the bigots, Smith College graduates will be deprived of the thoughts of Christine Lagarde, chief of the International Monetary Fund. She withdrew this week, under pressure from people who object to the I.M.F.’s role in the “strengthening of imperialist and patriarchal systems.” So, one of the world’s most powerful women will not share insights with one of the nation’s most prominent women’s colleges because of a concern about patriarchy. Evil men — that’ll show ’em.

This was followed by the swift departure of Robert J. Birgeneau, a former chancellor of the University of California, Berkeley, as a speaker at Haverford College. Yes, you heard that right: The man from Berkeley is not suitable for the sensitive souls of Haverford.

For guidance, these censors could have consulted the Rutgers student mission statement. “We embrace difference by cultivating inclusiveness and respect of both people and points of view.” Diversity of perspective? Thy name should be academia. But of late, too many schools are opting for well-vetted bores. Pursue your dream, live your own life, don’t forget to floss or use sunscreen, and if you’re forced to share a hall with people you don’t like, shout them down and kick them out the door. (read the whole thing)

67 comments:

chickelit said...

That's quite a change in editorial tone for the NYT. Did something change to allow such unbridled opinion there?

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

Did something change to allow such unbridled opinion there?

Maybe we need a philosopher to answer such an imponderable ;)



bagoh20 said...

Just admitting the obvious about censorship does not mean you are able to consider the arguments of dissenters like an adult, NYT.

"CLIMATE SCIENCE DEFECTOR FORCED TO RESIGN BY ALARMIST 'FATWA'"

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

Did something change to allow such unbridled opinion there?

Not exactly a "A vehement lamentation like that of Job."

But as close as Chick gets.

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

It's hard to know who drives these protests. Most faculty are too stressed doing research, writing grants or teaching to give a fuck and the students are generally apathetic to anything that doesn't affect their grades. It would be a very small percentage of the university population who would even know who the commencement speaker was. The people at fault here are the administrators for bowing to a tiny subset of their university.

Chip Ahoy said...

climate-denial

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

Now that there is funny! ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

Oh Lordy! ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

Nobody. And I mean NOBODY denies climate ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

Everything falls apart after that. Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

That is simply the stupidest fucking thing I ever heard. Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

Timothy Egan you are one stupid fucker. Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

chickelit said...

@ARM: During my time at UW-Madison, a tiny subset of lefty students opposed an on campus speech given by Eldridge Cleaver. They successfully shouted him down. This was circa 1982. Since then, I've always associated such tactics exclusively with the left. I can't think of a suitable counter example of the right shouting down a speaker. Can you?

bagoh20 said...

What he did there is the equivalent of excoriating bigotry against Blacks, women, gays and Hispanics and then adding, "but those damned Jews."

chickelit said...

(from Bagoh20's link with emphasis added):
The Swedish climatologist, meteorologist, former director of the Max Planck Institute for Meteorology in Hamburg and winner, in 2006, of the 51st IMO Prize of the World Meteorological Organization for his pioneering work in numerical weather prediction...

This proves that it's opinion-driven, IMO.

edutcher said...

Maybe somebody at the gray Lady has read a biography of Maximilien Robespierre.

AnUnreasonableTroll said...

It's hard to know who drives these protests. Most faculty are too stressed doing research, writing grants or teaching to give a fuck and the students are generally apathetic to anything that doesn't affect their grades.

Community organizers?

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

Here is a good example of a right wing/christian protest. The preponderance of left wing protests simply reflects the fact that students are predominantly liberal. The same dynamic is at work at right wing universities.

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

"AnUnreasonableTroll said..."

You don't have to do that ed... lets try to keep it civil, ok?

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

Special Ed, I am requesting that you put me on ignore. I find your quotations of, and responses to, my comments moronic in the extreme and rather than have a flame war about you chronic unemployability I am politely requesting that you ignore everything I write in future. Would this really be so difficult?

Known Unknown said...

The Liberty protest wasn't very effective.

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

Timothy Egan throes some red meat to the people he is excoriating.

He can't even do what he is proposing, that people be allowed to speak freely.

ChipA is absolutely right to laugh, it's pretty funny

I'm Full of Soup said...

As Chip Ahoy noted with his trademark humor, the dweeb NYT writer had to take a shot a Repubs while propping up a somewhat questionable choice,the foreigner from the IMF Christine Lagarde.

ARM: it only took one nutty professor and about 50 Rutgers students [mostly Muslim leaning] to get Condi's visit waylaid. It is amazing how 50 or so idiots can get so much publicity.

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

throes? I meant throws...

bagoh20 said...

It's an astounding lack of self-awareness required in this context to say "... extremism, whether in the climate-denial echo chamber of Republican Party elites...".

Is the climate echo chamber any more profound than among the Democratic elites? It IS the religion as much as catholicism at the Vatican.

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

AJ Lynch said...
ARM: it only took one nutty professor and about 50 Rutgers students


University administrators are remarkably risk averse when it comes to bad publicity, much like public company CEOs. There are no principles only PR.

chickelit said...

@ARM: Did Romney in fact speak there?

Prayers and angry letters to the editor are one thing but physical shout-downs are quite another. Witness all the anti-Walker attempts to shout down Sarah Palin and Andrew Breitbart in Madison a few years ago now. These were physical manifestations of intolerance. Emphasis on physical.

May the left is just more viscerally vicious.

I'm Full of Soup said...

Lem - if ARM's ID name was "A Brilliant Man" should we not lampoon him for that?

If so, I don't think khe should get amnesty for thining he is oh so reasonable afterall he and Ritmo call Edutcher every name in the book at times.

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

I was spinning a yarn using the last 'firenado' post and this topic of commencement bigots.

It thought I had it but it's not quite turning out like I thought it could.

the only salvageable part of the ordeal is "tornadoes are left wing and firenadoes are right wing".

That sounds funny in my head btw. just thought I let you know.

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

AJ Lynch said...
If so, I don't think khe should get amnesty for thining he is oh so reasonable afterall he and Ritmo call Edutcher every name in the book at times.


I very rarely respond to Ed and even more rarely respond with names. I responded this time because his name calling was so gratuitous. I am in basic agreement with everyone here that this kind of censorship is unreasonable. I can understand the negative responses to Anne Coulter, she actively provokes those responses as part of her business plan but most speakers should be heard either in respectful silence or simply ignored if you disagree.

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

if ARM's ID name was "A Brilliant Man" should we not lampoon him for that?

I guess... All I'm saying is give peace a chance... or something.

Everybody seems convinced that civility is the best thing, so lets go for it. that's all I'm saying.

Lets try to be tolerant of Ed too. No more name calling.

That's coming from Gloria Akalitus btw ;)

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

chickenlittle said...
Prayers and angry letters to the editor are one thing but physical shout-downs are quite another.


An example of this was given in the linked article:


'Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. recently canceled an address at the graduation ceremony of the Oklahoma City police academy after he was harassed by gun nuts and Republican elected officials ... Organizers called for officers in attendance to “place Holder in handcuffs.” '

chickelit said...

'Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. recently canceled an address at the graduation ceremony of the Oklahoma City police academy after he was harassed by gun nuts and Republican elected officials ... Organizers called for officers in attendance to “place Holder in handcuffs.” '

I happen to think Holder is a criminal and should be jailed for obstructing justice, which is worse than handcuffs when you think about it.

But these are still words. Shouted words and vezuvelas such as at a speech are measurable in dB and have an audible suppressing effect. I'm still waiting for you to find the example of shout down to help disprove my 10:45 hypothesis.

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

He had to cancel the address, just like the other examples. What's different here?

chickelit said...

He had to cancel the address, just like the other examples. What's different here?

Holder has the Coulter disease? He's a drama queen. There are other examples of his haughty remarks to support this.

Chip S. said...

One thing I never see in any reports about these protests is a description of the process by which the commencement speakers are chosen. Is there really no student input on these things? If there is student input, why do we never hear from them when the invitation is revoked?

The other point that gets ignored is that a last-minute disinvite has cost the speaker the opportunity to speak somewhere where (s)he's welcome.

edutcher said...


Special Ed how droll,

I am requesting that you put me on ignore. I find your quotations of, and responses to, my comments moronic in the extreme and rather than have a flame war about you chronic unemployability

Flame all you want, it just emphasizes your unwillingness at addressing issues.

I am politely requesting that you ignore everything I write in future. Would this really be so difficult?

Yes, since all I did was offer a possible answer to your rather duplicitous statement.

And, once again, we see that such an answer brings only cheap shots devoid of rebuttal.

Lem says be civil, and I thought I was, but, I do as he asks.

Too bad civility is one way street.

Synova said...

Er... so the rhetorical rule holds that if you're going to criticize liberals you must first stake out a Republican sacrificial lamb to soften them up?

Exactly *who* have Republican climate denialists shut down, disinvited, protested or shunned?

Anyone?

Chip S. said...

Also remember that while Democrats have leaders, Republicans have elites.

Synova said...

It looks like Romney spoke. The thing about Holder is sort of odd... it sounds like the protest was separate from the academy. I will give ARM this, though, the *only* examples I've seen in comments elsewhere of examples of "conservatives" doing this (the *only* one) was Obama being "shouted down" by a two word exclamation by one guy... and this was apparently a serious comparison. So good job finding something at least in the realm of sanity.

In my mind, though, what's almost more alarming (if it can be called alarming) about the protests are the justifications for them. Sure, any school can chose not to invite any particular speaker... but the justifications are insane.

The assumption that The Students uniformly despise and will be insulted by Condi Rice is beyond irrational. We're supposed to listen to The Students, and The Student's Voice... the "paying customer"... as if instead of a tiny minority, even on an elite liberal campus, the loud children represent them all.

And while it's fairly easy to see why Condi would be controversial, or a Mormon at Falwell's campus, the deal with Birgeneau or Christine Legarde is just insane.

The comments are SO incredibly self-important, as well as utterly *grandiose* in pretension when one of these fellow travelers shows up to explain how obviously right it is to have everything exactly their way...

I have to remind myself that I've got first hand contact with college students and I've seen the eyes that roll at the silliness of it all. To be certain, there's not much pushback from other students because the vast *vast* majority of them have better things to do with their lives.

bagoh20 said...

And Democrats have consensus, while Republicans have an echo chamber.

Trooper York said...

Keep it civil?

Does that mean I can't call you a greasy Dominican Red Sox butt boy?

Where's the fun in that?

Trooper York said...

Oh yeah and don't forget this!!!!!!

bagoh20 said...

I just can't stop pointing out the many layers of myopia of the single statement. Like calling the dissenting voices an echo chamber as opposed to the people who often state that their main reason for agreeing is that others agree (a consensus).

Chip S. said...

I think we should all focus on our shared values, and send a big Thank You! to the Sheriff's department of Kitsap County, WA, for finding Casey Kasem.

Trooper York said...

Yes that's very true.

I guess he will no longer be in the top forty of missing persons.

Chip S. said...

I was surprised that he was really lost.

I'd assumed he was just standing under his wife's bosom, and nobody could see him.

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

Trooper is still up after 1 am?

Go to bed old man ;)

Leland said...

So I saw where a true humanitarian wrote about a Sheriff's department finding Casey Kasem. And although I haven't paid much attention to Casey Kasem, and his loss, while personally sad for his family, would mean little to me; the true humanitarian suggested I should thank the sheriff's office. And since it was a true humanitarian that suggested this, who am I (just a regular Joe with a name) not to honor a true humanitarian. I'm a reasonable man, right?

AReasonableMan said...

Leland said...
I'm a reasonable man, right?


Sorry buddy, but there only be one AReasonableMan. You can be UnreasonableTroll or Unreasonable Bitch, those descriptors are still available. Special Ed is also available, at least until next time Ed decides to stray off the civility reservation.

Aridog said...

Well, for one, I refuse to be even slightly civil to one particular interloper from another blog. He only shows up to cause irritation and sometimes pain to others, and he enjoys it. He gets hostile and more insulting the minute you call him on it. On the rare occasion I interact with this clown I start right off insulting on purpose....it is the best he deserves.

I'm Full of Soup said...

Chip S. has hilariously skewered names like The Moderate Voice while adhering to Lem's plea for civility. Excellent work Chip!

Chip S. said...

As they say in Hollywood,

based on an idea by AJ Lynch

Chip S. said...

I'd completely forgotten about "The Moderate Voice". What a joke.

I commented there for a while, then moved to TOP when TMV started moderating comments for "civility", which in practice meant, "never make fun of foolish comments by silly leftists."

edutcher said...


Sorry buddy, but there only be one AReasonableMan. You can be UnreasonableTroll or Unreasonable Bitch, those descriptors are still available. Special Ed is also available, at least until next time Ed decides to stray off the civility reservation.

No, everyone here qualifies but one and he is patently uncivil, whereas Leland, whom I remember from TOP, is always civil, so he should call himself a reasonable man.

PS Hmmm, up all night, commenting in the morning.

I know, the boss is out of town, right?

AReasonableMan said...

edutcher said...
No, everyone here qualifies but one and he is patently uncivil


Ed you are delusional on this. Phx, R&B and myself all find you reflexively offensive. The problem is you buddy. Althouse kicked you off her site for the same reason. Once again, please refrain from responding to my posts. It doesn't add anything of value to the discussion. This is not personal, I think we should try to respect Lem's overall ethos. If we were on TOP I would have a different attitude.

edutcher said...

Delusional?

Nobody was kicked off.

I left.

You followed.

Sad.

PPS Boss still out, I see.

bagoh20 said...

" Lem's overall ethos."

I'm not respecting that. I don't care if it does get me banned.

TrooperYork said...

Wait a cotton pickin' minute like Crack used to say.

I thought this was Lem's overall ethos!

Don't confuse us bags!

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

bagoh20 said...
" Lem's overall ethos."

I'm not respecting that. I don't care if it does get me banned.


No one is getting banned. It gets tedious dealing with Ed. It's deja vu all over again. I am simply asking that he doesn't respond to my posts and preferably to phx and R&B's posts either. He only ever has negative snarky things to say so this doesn't seem to be a large request. Apparently we have nothing of value to say so ignoring our useless shit should be no big deal. Ed seemed to believe that he was protecting the purity of the internet at TOP but I doubt the internet cares what is said here.

Imagine if the roles were reversed and you had some nut-job calling you names every time you posted on this site. Wouldn't you find that tedious after a while?

bagoh20 said...

That was before the highly successful diet of whiskey and jalapeno flavored peeps.

It's a purging regime that really knocks off the pounds.

President-Mom-Jeans said...

Negative snarky things are the most interesting ones.

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

President-Mom-Jeans said...
Negative snarky things are the most interesting ones.


Given your views on this issue it would seem to make sense that Ed should direct all his energies towards your brilliant posts - it's a match made in heaven.

Chip S. said...

Just as long as there's no blanket policy that would ban ricpic from calling̶ R̶i̶t̶m̶o̶ Rhythm and Balls "Montana Urban Schmendrick".

I have no idea what it means, but it cracks me up every time.

Trooper York said...

"Imagine if the roles were reversed and you had some nut-job calling you names every time you posted on this site. Wouldn't you find that tedious after a while?"

It happens to me all the time but eventually his master calls and he has to go home to mow the lawn. So you just have to ignore it. Guy's married to bossy blonds have to have an outlet where they are not constantly emasculated. Let them act like tough guys on the internet. They look foolish but I guess it makes them feel like He-men.

bagoh20 said...

"Montana Urban Schmendrick"

Ditto to that. It's pure poetry.

Trooper York said...

It is a term of endearment.

edutcher said...

All this because I don't let somebody get away with spreading falsehoods.

Poor little Lefty, his feelings are hurt.

I should go into business starting wars or something.

Trooper York said...

Guy's married to bossy blonds have to have an outlet where they re not constantly emasculated.

Sounds like projection to me.

edutcher said...

PS In the name of clarity, let's all agree any Lefty who goes on a mildly Conservative blog and calls himself AReasonableMan is doing more than a little battle space prep.

Kind of like talking about A-house Hillbillies.

Unknown said...

LOL - Chip S. (I know - late to the party) You are hilarious. Thank you.

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

edutcher said...
All this because I don't let somebody get away with spreading falsehoods.


Ed, not to belabor the point, but you genuinely believe and regularly state that Romney really won the last election. And, you did not point out any falsehood, you simply made yet another inane snarky remark.

But, it seems we are all in agreement, just put me on ignore. I want to be ignored by you.

Meade said...

edutcher said...
Trooper York said...
Guy's married to bossy blonds have to have an outlet where they re not constantly emasculated.


Sounds like projection to me.
May 16, 2014 at 6:41 PM
------------------------------------

Boy, when edutcher gets one right (rare), he gets it exactly right.

Trooper York said...

See that Eddie. With friends like Leisure Suit Larry who needs enemies?

Trooper York said...

See that Eddie. With friends like Leisure Suit Larry who needs enemies?