Showing posts with label Nobel Peace Prize. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nobel Peace Prize. Show all posts

Thursday, September 17, 2015

Nobel Official says Obama Peace Prize did not have desired effect

Geir Lundestad stepped down last year as non-voting secretary of the committee. He wrote in a book released today that the committee had expected the award to give a boost to Obama. [Amazon Geir Lundestad ]

ABC News reports this surprised the committee when instead the award was met with fierce criticism in the U.S., where many argued Obama had not been president long enough to have any impact worthy of the Nobel and even his supporters believed the prize a mistake.

This is how they think,
"...in that sense the committee didn't achieve what it had hoped for."
No. It did not achieve what it had hoped for. He is admitting to hoping for a political boost that didn't happen, and not to admitting to increased world peace, bad enough because it is still not achievement. Pretty much all Americans saw what the Nobel Committee did not, we saw them squandering their institution for their preferred politics, they conflated what they want for what is, what people actually did. They dishonored themselves and the award.

It's your webpage.
According to Nobel's will, the Peace Prize is to go to whoever "shall have done the most or the best work for fraternity between nations, for the abolition or reduction of standing armies and for the holding and promotion of peace congresses". 
See the problem, the whole past tense thing? Cart, horse and all that. Maybe the "shall have done" construction threw you guys off, what is that, subjunctive past pluperfect? No wait, that would be "would had done." It's tricky, we'll put your wish casting with deadly important matters aside, we'll ignore your typical liberal 'create-your-own-reality' approach to running important global institutions, we'll elide over you destroying your own credibility and cut you some slack, that past-tense achievement thing could have been stated more simply and more emphatically. It could have just said, "whatever our panel would like to happen." Just change it. Do what you like.

We learn Obama called the committee, not to discover if more worthy people were passed over in favor of him, rather, to find out if other winners had skipped the award ceremony.

The article begins, "In a break with Nobel tradition, the former secretary to the committee says the 2009 award to President Obama failed to live up to the panel's expectations.

That wasn't the break with tradition. Awarding for political support and not achievement as mandated is the break with tradition. We're glad you regret it.

Friday, March 7, 2014

Irena Sendler

Yesterday's news that Vladimir Putin has been nominated for a Nobel Peace Prize stands as a reminder of how flawed and politically correct the Nobel selection process has become in recent years.  Consider the 2007 Peace Prize.

Irena Sendler and Albert Gore, Jr. were nominated for the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize.  The Nobel Committee awarded the Peace Prize to Gore, based largely on Gore having written the book An Inconvenient Truth: The Planetary Emergency of Global Warming and What We Can Do About It, in which Gore claimed that human-caused global warming is a settled scientific fact.   Gore's book was later seen as bunk, with more than 30,000 scientists signing a petition that flatly denied the claims made in Gore's book.

You may not have heard of Irena Sendler.  Her name has not become a household word.  She didn't write a book, or run for elected office.  Yet her Nobel nomination was jointly submitted by the President of Poland and the Prime Minister of Israel.
What did Irena Sendler do that merited a Nobel Peace Prize nomination?  She didn't write a book of climatological fiction; she merely smuggled 2,500 children out of the Warsaw ghetto, saving them from being sent to their deaths in Nazi camps.