Friday, March 7, 2014

Irena Sendler

Yesterday's news that Vladimir Putin has been nominated for a Nobel Peace Prize stands as a reminder of how flawed and politically correct the Nobel selection process has become in recent years.  Consider the 2007 Peace Prize.

Irena Sendler and Albert Gore, Jr. were nominated for the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize.  The Nobel Committee awarded the Peace Prize to Gore, based largely on Gore having written the book An Inconvenient Truth: The Planetary Emergency of Global Warming and What We Can Do About It, in which Gore claimed that human-caused global warming is a settled scientific fact.   Gore's book was later seen as bunk, with more than 30,000 scientists signing a petition that flatly denied the claims made in Gore's book.

You may not have heard of Irena Sendler.  Her name has not become a household word.  She didn't write a book, or run for elected office.  Yet her Nobel nomination was jointly submitted by the President of Poland and the Prime Minister of Israel.
What did Irena Sendler do that merited a Nobel Peace Prize nomination?  She didn't write a book of climatological fiction; she merely smuggled 2,500 children out of the Warsaw ghetto, saving them from being sent to their deaths in Nazi camps.


 Irena Sendler, born in 1910, was raised by her Catholic parents to respect and love people regardless of their ethnicity or social status. Her father, a physician, died from typhus that he contracted during an epidemic in 1917. He was the only doctor in his town near Warsaw who would treat the poor, mostly Jewish victims of this tragic disease. As he was dying, he told 7-year-old Irena, "If you see someone drowning you must try to rescue them, even if you cannot swim." In 1939 the Nazis swept through Poland and imprisoned the Jews in ghettos where they were first starved to death and then systematically murdered in killing camps. Irena, by than a social worker in Warsaw, saw the Jewish people drowning and resolved to do what she could to rescue as many as possible, especially the children.

Working with a network of other social workers and brave Poles, mostly women, she smuggled 2,500 children out of the Warsaw ghetto and hid them safely until the end of the war. Sendler took great risks - obtaining forged papers for the children, disguising herself as an infection control nurse, diverting German occupation funds for the support of children in hiding. She entered the Warsaw ghetto, sometimes two and three times a day, and talked Jewish parents into giving up their children. Sendler drugged the babies with sedatives and smuggled them past Nazi guards in gunny sacks, boxes and coffins. She helped the older ones escape through the sewers, through secret openings in the wall, through the courthouse, through churches, any clever way she and her network could evade the Nazis.

Once outside the ghetto walls, Sendler gave the children false names and documents and placed them in convents, orphanages and with Polish families. In 1942 the Polish underground organization ZEGOTA recruited her to lead their Children's Division, providing her with money and support. Her hope was that after the war she could reunite the children with surviving relatives, or at least return their Jewish identities. To that end she kept thin tissue paper lists of each child's Jewish name, their Polish name and address. She hid the precious lists in glass jars buried under an apple tree in the back yard of one of her co-conspirators.

In 1943 Irena Sendler was arrested, tortured and sentenced to death by firing squad. She never divulged the location of the lists or her Polish underground contacts. At the last moment she was saved by ZEGOTA which bribed a guard to secure her freedom. She still bears the scars and disability of her torture.

 Irena Sendler died in 2008. Her death was noted in the New York Times.   The NYT, of course, did not mention Sendler's Nobel nomination.

You can read more about Irena Sandler at irenasandler.org, including how her story was discovered by students in rural Kansas, researched, and made into a stage play called Life in a Jar.




37 comments:

Unknown said...

Wow Haz. This is a fantastic post. I had no idea.

The Nobel prize went to a fraud and a wealthy scam artist, while they ignored a real hero.

I have NO respect for the Nobel prize. It's become another authoritarian leftwing bullshit prize applauding fraudulent authoritarian leftwing bullshit artists.

edutcher said...

That's what it's all about.

Courage in the face of near-certain death.

But, instead, it goes to Mr Carbon Credit and President Drone.

bagoh20 said...

That such selfless heroism goes unacknowledged and thus less imitated is the tragic and very real cost of the disgusting ideology worship the left plays with such things.

When you read of someone like Irena Sendler you are just humbled by the knowledge that no matter how decent you may imagine yourself to be, you can always do a lot better. That should be the lesson of things like the Nobel Prize.

ndspinelli said...

Haz, You are an MVP. Most Valuable Poster.

chickelit said...

April Apple: The Nobel prize went to a fraud and a wealthy scam artist, while they ignored a real hero.

Keep in mind that the Swedes award the science prizes while the Norges award only the Peace Prize.

How did it get that way? Dunno. But it must give the Norges an inferiority complex.

XRay said...

Yes, great post and thoughtful reminder of how the world has changed, where we ignore our hero's and glamorize the incompentent.

I wonder if Irena knew this gentleman who just passed, another hero gone.

“Cigarette sellers of Three Crosses Square”,

Unknown said...

When one branch of the Nobel prize hand out awards like a Hugo Chavez ribbon committee, the others should feel embarrassed. It's embarrassing.

sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
rcocean said...

I must have missed that 30,000 scientist petition too. Gore Nobel prize was a joke, but then Woodrow Wilson, Cordell Hull, Linus Pauling, the ILO, Begin, Kissinger, de Klerk, Arafat, Carter, Obama, and the EU (!) have gotten it.

Its even more worthless than the Noble Literature prize. Its just whoever some left-wing Scandis like at a particular moment.

Michael Haz said...

Here is a link to the Global Warming Petition Project. It has more than 30,000 signers.

I note with amusement that the defense of Al Gore is more important to some than Irena Sendler, the actual subject of this topic,

sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
deborah said...

Amazing story, Haz, thanks.

Michael Haz said...

phx, I am not certain why you believe a bullshit detector is necessary. Do you realize that the list is verified?

Perhaps you can address your suspicion of bullshit to the project's founders:

Arthur B. Robinson, BS Caltech, PhD UCSD
Professor of Chemistry
Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine
artr@oism.org

Noah E. Robinson, BS SOU, PhD Caltech
Professor of Chemistry
Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine
noahr@oism.org

Signatories are approved for inclusion in the Petition Project list if they have obtained formal educational degrees at the level of Bachelor of Science or higher in appropriate scientific fields. The petition has been circulated only in the United States.

The current list of petition signers includes 9,029 PhD; 7,157 MS; 2,586 MD and DVM; and 12,715 BS or equivalent academic degrees. Most of the MD and DVM signers also have underlying degrees in basic science.

All of the listed signers have formal educations in fields of specialization that suitably qualify them to evaluate the research data related to the petition statement. Many of the signers currently work in climatological, meteorological, atmospheric, environmental, geophysical, astronomical, and biological fields directly involved in the climate change controversy.

But then, you probably know more abut this that the 30,000+ people who signed the petition.

Have yo actually read through the petition's website, by the way? Or is this just your knee-jerk response?

Trooper York said...

His knee has nothing to do with it.

Trooper York said...


"Your tribute to Irena Sendler was great, fine, well said."

Translation:
"Big whoops, some old lady saved a bunch of Jews why are we talking about that. Old news. What difference at this point does it make. Don't even take a minute to acknowledge that for crying out loud. Fine and dandy. Just don't diss the climate warming gurus who use their private jets to fly to spas to get that "special massage."

Aridog said...

You know what. I am sick of this fucking place. I need to be gone for a while.

See ya.

chickelit said...

I just looked at Haz's link. Isn't that signature Edward Teller's? That alone explains why lefties knee-jerked this petition.

chickelit said...

Aridog said...
You know what. I am sick of this fucking place. I need to be gone for a while.

See ya.


Send me an email and I'll send you real contact info.

Stay in touch.

sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
chickelit said...

It's a little disingenuous for you to claim the high road here IMO.

Not all. Sendler clearly did more as an individual than Gore did by any humanitarian measure. I think Gore himself would agree. Gore is more or less an errand boy sent by grocery clerks to collect a bill.

The Nobel Peace Prize has lost its prestige by almost anyone's measure, given the range of recipients. It is symbolic. Even Obama has self-depricated once or twice as to "what did I really do?"

As for why Sendler was never nominated -- you'd have to reach back to the history of the prize, all the way to 1945 or so. The Prizes were originally intended to honor recipient's works in the near recent past. Ten years after the end of the war, they were still giving out WW II related prizes, but mainly to leaders of organizations and UN leaders, etc.

sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Trooper York said...

Not. It is pointing out the life story of someone who I was not aware of and who I now admire greatly and will attempt to find out more about if I can. She seems to me to be a hero and an example to us all.

It seems to dismiss her out of hand as no big deal to protect someone like ManBearPig is a much more egregious political move but YMMV.

This woman is an example of the type of person who should have been honored instead of politicians like Obama or Gore or Putin or Arafat or any of those who have won it in recent years.

Trooper York said...

I am glad that Michael Haz taught me about her and I thank him for that.

sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
chickelit said...

Sendler and Gore represent two disparate notions of what gets awarded by the peace prize committees. The first type is for acts, which Sendler clearly belonged. As I tried to make clear, she should have been nominated much much earlier before she termed out of consideration because of distance in time. These sorts of people deserve well made biopics, like "Shindler's List."

Gore represents the second kind of winner which is to say someone who lacks deed or substance but whose message the committee hopes will have a wider affect. In the case of Obama especially, it was an award not based on merit, but rather on the hope and promise that they sincerely believed he would deliver.

I think it's terribly wrong to award these sorts of enticement prizes. They need to go back to focussing on deeds and finding the Norman Borlaug's of the world.

Trooper York said...

It is not bashing Al Gore and Barack Obama to say that their Nobel Peace Prizes were absolute jokes and just a big farce. It is simply the truth.

It would be the same thing if we gave the Super Bowl MVP to the teams announcer. They are great at talking not doing.

Trooper York said...

It is your cavalier dismissal of this wonderful woman that is disturbing phx. You have to defend ManBearPig at all costs. You so partisan.

Now I have to go put on my mantle of self-righteousness and argue with Little Debbie about poetry.

chickelit said...

Message to the Nobel Committee: Stop trying the steer the world through promise; reward only good works and deeds.

virgil xenophon said...

Gee, what pissed Aridog off? This place is nothing like TOP. Anyone?

Signed: ABSOLUTELY Clueless..

Trooper York said...

I think it was Ritmo in a post about Obamacare. He has a way of getting under your skin because he knows what buttons to push.

Michael Haz said...

You're completely unable to imagine how anyone who admired Al Gore or was sympathetic to his presentation of global change could ever see this as anything other than a simple heart-felt tribute to a deserving woman.

Wait wait wait. You're the one who turned this topic into an admiration fest for Al Gore. Couldn't you just admire Irena Sendler and leave it at that?

sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sakredkow said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Michael Haz said...

Okay, phx, peace.